CAS 2019 A 6667 Patrice-Edouard Ngaïssona v. FIFA

TRTEARTTTRATTN TR SPORT Mr Skli P. Pilavici, Almmey ul luw ir Atui, rcucuMr Philippe Sumn:, KC, urriter in Londeor, Uniled KingdonMr Munie Nim, Allommey at law in Aniwrlarn, hu Nuthurlarus ARHITR A1 . A.WA.II) Alexander Knoop: nd M: .J. rlelivered by tlr. AHHITRAL1.-1IT.A-3.11.6. LPARTIESMr Pairicc-Lure Nμissoau (u: Appdnnt ia_ n fornmer centnl Alficunepublic: Miuisteu for Yonth anet Speit nnd haa ield,, tr rer llc lolluvirycARA.Menmherftheruunisingpsitics:Menbet 'the ll'A Murbr Assuitius cnlnicc:.TcdertimnTntmitinle"A"i" aesuuiatio lkuZurich, Switzurkeul. FltAw,uklwiclc:fficil md layer wrlwilk.FACTUAL BACKGRLNDTaelgrund FuctxHrlnw is n smmary f the 1elevanl laul and alluuatius Liaccf cn 1hc: Pmitica?witten nd al itibmiwsiusal uvilux.A.gliitinnl fw rclvnt,_tIL,Wisile the Pnnel hn consicered all Lhe Iaul allaatiurls.evidence ubmiled by thu,Iarlita,irl tli: cgent ronecelinma, it refers in itrAarl ly tu sluxissimsits xcsoninf.Th baekauurl te t thia cnae conern thesiixx: anla in th Centrni Africnn Repulie cGAR). ln sunmuisiuu uis iothis seotion, the Panel relien on che pluudinns cr u Jautics, anrl wisheanike ceia thtt il isi nt ki Lirlia cr its ow.The Selecn,i n redeminanlly Milirn arud aruu which cimcrnerl in aoi2,is sni o huv Laken puwur lrur, _Al Irtsiclent, at the: tinme, Trnngois Tozize.urcl lrcut hiru inlu cxj., Miehel I>jntnclin, n Seleka leuder. heuarnu Prusidlcnlul aumnineel in thnt poaition until Junumry 2ol1.Dtiririg thu llist atreitica nncl vinlnion af intenational hlimunilariar lawformer, President Tsxive in the solcka, iaulitluia thu tinr nfrer Mnreh 2ol3u, atirn to hnve heemwhen the Sslka car tu p_wtr.Aceording to variour UN reporla, sinuu,u letuulx_cf the Selakn nttnelcs inwiclcspixet ul arve;vielntinna of hinnn "ightn, ineluding urbilrary urrusts 2012,tg uumry hs te fneinp n AS 20I9/A/tG7 Puic@ Eduard Narson Y. 1"A :cxrniaenwriltn suncl ornl anhnmisaions, and evidence,in conneetion with the legul iziclissian lt Aiicunetbal Aasuiliu (u:*osponlen+Svvissregulnty. Republic uultllCwluituM u' FHAlaw anc bnn itn reiatered fficeby Nuperviryistiucivil comflicl which is unoing CA 2(19/A/ehN/ 1*ri44t-Tl1 NM+11u V. F1l-AIHIEUJNAL ARITFA. DU S_I 1(" J F AF"YArIGN F SIC>1 -1t JN11AFFITRAL. EL. DEPCRTE1-1 t1 5fetcntion,exiulvi>lenue4CFchilfrnn,Tote,ra1ngete killirg,rcuruiluvut, ut,ilesleiera nndother nue, rupurkcoiLuututulidStillen leent mdThc aitntim W iariulrly,mlaraia Hari wherer E tIy.fncilitien, H; well as carjackia l euxl rolnrica, were cngoing.lootinenndilmering t huia,uilics,usix3sc:3deteriorsting.capial.Esturiysituntionn.IVauilelisi, uur rinhta vinlnticns nnd asult by Soloku ulute usinst theiviin olntic.was saicl te, hnve leenfommed,vilh tliu uirn ur ruuuvirp,Mih:l Tzioroclin fremnndountlingLheSolekafruu_A.:MT.AntiFtnlnlen.tagetedarutribtiun tu thu icns sf Meleen elements uguinsit the civilin pupultio, ferToslililisisl(I:Mslintwllitlx Miuglima werepereeive u; ceslleulivuly ruspuasibk ux, cumnplieit withr 1o+ive te $$1u.9.(_>1 ()Janunry2o14.Presicent Miuhtl ILDjoloulit ruiad.wi+lrewLLLXLJagui.uMuliumneteuled a xpuscl t usuli rarrimtive.tuurnign involved the reporled Lirgulinu cl' ho Mislinciviliu ruintion nnd thoue erueived L uvcI3lk Mup."I'E4,:Stppmtud (l glelenLC2etli,x.,.11i+,txs,killinca,tlnti", rLruatut, ipris,u " hn for fnevere oprivalio f'Eity,Muin myery clrcliuiuis buiia (mnaes),u so ao J,4,te le ytermlically crri _ulI,te have beun clareu ul uuuir, iusbirnnta. Rnneni's original'Muslin rcsicluntHy Pelnny zo , eurly all Muslir inh in Rnni Wene erudou y, Mareh 2ol4, Mont of wenle A's Musli pupulticn hndrctgc in the neighlsuring culinlrics.11.l Jur: ei 4, the Ttenntiomat Fedeatic lur lluiex Jialts (rTH) lliaheds rt on the ituution in Al (h l> awrt).I 2.>n y oi4,theFamel i Lxrlll l(cutralAfricnnimlerim rcporl which is tstotl r Jhne: 2"l4 to the Freident l chu LN SuwuirityCuuncil (u *lttin Kopo+)Cn 2g elcr 2ol, c Ian:l of Pxpcrta nn tie Cerlrul Aliican luputlic:thui Finnl rejoit which in daled 2s uubur 2o4 to thc: preaiclent f the TNcatablishud ursut, trScnrity_Gomcil rsitlulion2127 (2013) s.TOT WTITT., ) I ELOS AHHIIRAL14.Atadinn to, nmneat crheireorted to he one oytle mnit prornirunt Anti-atlakat lkeleusud l:lei the: postof the gereral,coorclinlor ur, ttege c/e/** (L), a,w na the"Ar e rfeshnatilitiea nzainnt the Seieku in csAR. This incluclecl atlauks ueirst t: civilinnFepulatin,diplucemunprupmrty ui rclinions illiga, rotine pilaging ofMunli houus t upsnnl craceticn in aeveral AR lcutic icenlifiu i c i purt.1 5.1'上u:conflict y identifyi hi cllurtsIslc:rahip wirhi he <:T.P:gratip wilhin hu uruenisatiut., leinteznticmnappointed new cumnundur uf uu uliag in he einof cdn, nnd evensiunucl un 23 July plt u aprnnnnntfnallitnted by thetiN secunily Counuil,a cnn: in mdintinn te renove the, cnilit r buhall'of thc Atileke16.Pnlnkn, one ot the cprpoing nidlea in a uulliut wliui was uo uiy n palitinnlfight,amtinsl au:Mluskiua nlnticnwna the c:t.Pc deulured luader,and is clucuununluu staas ilxnt th