CAS 2023 A 9386 Liaoning Shenyang Urban FC v. FIFA

11,INAL. ,14t1 t-AI . 1.3I 7() 1TRIBENAL. AFBITRAL. DEL LL:II Ttr_1_ I _>{ I I ,A <_ ,> Mr Jiauopo Tognun, Proluszur anl Altornuy-utLaw in Paova, llalyMr Ftraim nrnk, Alorrny-zl-Luw in 'l'cl Aviv, lsralMr Muark Anrew lluvell, Sulicitor in Marichuztur, Uniled Kingcloin FAHERAI.AWARIsitting in the folowing cmposiliun: intl 7. IRATN FC> nTARETRAL . IPGRTEIARTIEST.inoning Shenying rhun Fc (te. *APpallunt or Lh _luiby i ,ionl fatinllclhaulihe: ero e_,- _ IIA ( :*") i hcnrlnrrc:rg in 7a1rich, Sitzerlnnd."psitices', whcrc nplicnsle.I'I:A,fFA :T.AI.TACIOINYHersw ia n aimmniy "f the: relevnnr frct: nnd ullegatiors luned on Lhu arliu-cviduruw my be: awt uul.,wku:te: rrlvant. in cnnnention,with the legnl discuusin thutAddlitinal lcl lluutiurs lul i t Itisevidence smitted y the Purties in the Presenl prucuctinus, il xkrs in its A waul uiytc the uhmii and cviclcc il ciclkrs t,ssxy , 'xlni irs rcaaoninfLie eLinoni+loyu Fc: (Linuiu Fc!") wnt: ul:'s_Rtpnhiin fhinn. Tt sedtehe n enmler r Lhe c'A. Ir Lhe Rotballsenson: 2ni d 2oi, it ticiiea chin Lcacleugue compliirn rganizuu y h Cl'A.11 > 1cverduu Paysblus, Iruss autila qouacuuip Jionint Pia frnnnninl Hifficltica nnd itsderegixlered lre lhe Cssitl: listritili W; rnmrrnelly rlnnaed ns eary u* n 12 Mrch 2o20.Accurding lu inlurtiua uruyidu ty tx cHA,tl lnnnl ntity nperntine T.inoning Fc:va, alUit; tinxc of he FA clianiplinnryprneedingn, exiztenl,operutive and regiztorcdnrir thc: resective lnw; mnd wi nl iljeut irolvacy or brkrupt,y puclias.ireiw sherew rroer r?Iianing Shcnyauu, Lirtaht, was t scpnrnt footbnll ell, fenelnd in 2oI S nnd is lnsedalso i Shcyn, the Poogle'a Ralsiin of hinm. Tn the ethall ieanoms 20l6, 2o17.enge cnpetilicra organizucl by thc C'A. A r,sult t'thx Appllant rakin first in Whilethe Pnncl hna coiaieere all the fucti, ullegutiemi,,legul arglnents uMay 2020, :Assonintinn.tc CA").leignT.innig Fc alemg with lo cther Frulkssiuril loulbll clubswasby Iual,'sarttie_ of (hinn(tht:intcrntioni governing lody of footlallevidencu F^ah11PP? nwhichhcreinnfte"fennded in wxittcn subiriigsiona, nlcnclinga n he jcinrlyriaIgos nnd nsed iO, u ul ti 9.10.11.12.1'3.72214. ChiretLH:M,T.imnthc: :201)scn3mmn,itU(:hin J.cog ne stnrting from the 2ozo renn.I'h:Appull"niatcrcntlhc:shenyn11, Mnreh t(rao,the: alarehoidern nf theApellamt pve i; nw .the Shenyurig Fihall Aialiun (th: sfA> u ao Me aap snl ytle 1.innninnT.inonine Shenynng Trhan Fe.The chargo lhe APcllun'a naic was apuryia,tyProvinciml sprts ureu (lh: ]u .HsTApril o'. Jpon the Appelinnt's reqex:Jilf m a icaenbo2ozo, on, 8 Jnnunry 2o2i the CTA agnved il.: new nac andcnfirecl tlnt it. cofm wi he"Ntice ors thu Nor-rilcprisu Cl.Nner in Prefennional Luagus at All Luvula" isatua bx. ut: cihA. Jtis Worth notinn thntI.ianing is u uuslal uyviau iu Northonst hion nnd sheynne ia ita npitnl.Afrer Tiaoming Fc?'si dinaltiliuliun with tau Ct'A, tlaruu mrulisisyrrs rcvicnslyregisiurucl with Liauliu '_: i,iuwf inminp Mhnnynnr1Irhnn c. cne nlnyer thnt hndteAnellm1. cmtreits Lr-1o tenm ere reziatered with the Appellunt': rirl leum. uring th 2o2o susl,1s nuw playars, hru wl' whillIiuring Fc. uruuruuru. 2s suateur layrs_prcvionaly reniaterne wirh Tinoning c:iuil Apeant's ynth rmnms, TT-I., T JI3, TT..I4 nna TFCn 2.3 May 2o20, h: Apullut ullislxsl an its soinl melin n ileo which wnaraprtktlly uut te ray trimte tn T.inonine Tc:.m :2.5 Muy2020,a curuimuuy urguietlLy thu 1innninr Hnorhnll Aaaoeintion (the"LtA"> tuok alat: chrinn whinh the T.ps, nwnrded the Apelnmnt the fugof "NewIiszan/xinnhm*, (>n it Weilo rofile, the Apjellianl iannouncud tal il willcorliril:the: slenefline of T.i FLhzllunl tuke up hu hislorical nissiul wl' rvitaliei aneddevelping Iionig l'ottlln I3 Angunt 2o, amiher nag oerutnony wan rauizucl by t LrA, furi wkiclxthe liy o+New I.iaz**:. T.T. TT TM RMrrtm ?e Die Reafi c'bePrFYiamte Resoluation chamher (theFiFA DRc") uduruu Liuninn Ft_: l,py ta(_>1Nl1 ,t1eSingleJudgretheinlcrcsil.y.cf, as ul'a uye f rhe rh: dnte: nf cneh inatniment imtii the dnte nf effectiveA,(1h)Y>F:Tecirion".L.rtie>LheTA Tk: were exeluniveiy Ciremi a Lhu clairnant a Liunirig Ht_: as tk lxspulliat.The deciion ol'the FlliA Lic: was ulilivtl tu tht: partits t thu: clistuute nn 1 Ieremher201 .Cn 28 Muy 2oo, dluu Lo cn-urpliauue ul'Limuniun F: witl t tltA 1>kt.: Jnision,reyislrati tu ws ilsuntl trn 1inoinn F'i fnr +he mnximm cirntion of upta rt: xtii; nnel aensaative regixtrntien yericd. T3.I i.17.1 $.1 :3.20.21..3...2.3. Proceeingx before (he rlrA Liscipliirs ommitiretnfer of nnsets ar well the trnfer f right ind dutie: firn eI Jume 2n22, Cremic reqerited thc Sccrclriul lo thu lfA Lisiplinsty ,mmnitteeKV.a)Fcuaus tu tlicve Uat ttu Apprliant aheid he cnnaiderednnd trented nr the tperlinapr,chi,xs, nist te Appelinnt na it hndstrcsac of 1.inonine Fc: nnel therefore le linlle fer the dehl incurred by Lhe: laltur irnecordnnce with the T^ T>R Teoisic.(.su X Anst a(r?, (trenmio aupyenented its rege:t.n ,Aunust 2ozz.u: FitA Ic: rpned invostigntinna nfninst t