OC&C's Annual Marketplace Report: The Next Wave of Digital Marketplaces
Introduction
OC&C's comprehensive study on the world's top 250 digital marketplaces, based on Gross Merchandise Value (GMV), explores their evolution and growth in a post-pandemic era. The research employs a bottom-up approach, focusing on both large-scale platforms like Amazon and Alibaba (with combined consumer spend exceeding $500 billion) and emerging marketplaces with under $100 million in GMV.
Marketplace Growth and Trends
Marketplaces collectively account for $4.1 trillion in annual gross consumer spend as of 2022, with third-party sales dominating at $3.4 trillion. Over the past three years, marketplaces have seen a significant expansion from $2.4 trillion in 2019 to $4.1 trillion in 2022, adding $1.6 trillion in total consumer spend worldwide. Key categories include consumer-facing sectors such as ticketing, travel, food delivery, and more, excluding autos, real estate, and broader service-based marketplaces. For more detailed insights on optimizing online propositions, refer to OC&C's Retail Proposition Index.
Marketplace Segment Analysis
Marketplaces can be categorized into two types: First-party (1P) where the platform acts as the retailer, and third-party (3P) where sellers manage their own inventory. The 1P segment represents $1.7 trillion in consumer spend, while the 3P segment boasts $3.4 trillion. The 3P segment grew by 33% in 2021 and 34% in 2022, compared to the 1P segment's growth of 15.6% and 19.6%.
Category-Specific Consumer Spend
In selected categories, online marketplaces significantly influence consumer spending:
- Books: 33% share, $30 billion
- Furniture/Homeware: 74%, $710 billion
- Grocery: 68%, $107 billion
- Clothing & Accessories: 34%, $520 billion
- Travel: 27%, $240 billion
- Consumer Electronics: 32%, $190 billion
- Home Appliances: 60%, $190 billion
- Food Delivery: 13%, $30 billion
- Ticketing: 18%, $14 billion
- DIY/Garden/Pets: 78%, $680 billion
- Personal Care: 94%, $1,360 billion
Marketplace Dynamics
Generalist models, such as Amazon, have been dominant for over a decade. However, there's a surge in specialist models, including vertical-focused, second-hand, and hyper-local marketplaces, particularly outside China. These specialist models have outpaced generalists by 1.6 times in terms of 3P GMV growth (36% per annum vs 23% per annum, 2019-2022). As a result, mid-sized marketplaces are growing rapidly, with 8 marketplaces surpassing $10 billion in 3P GMV and 34 marketplaces reaching over $1 billion in 3P GMV since 2019, with over half being vertical specialists.
Marketplace Landscape
The European marketplace landscape is notably fragmented, with consumers accustomed to specialist and vertical-focused direct retail e-commerce models. This trend is driven by differences in category-level growth, with some categories sustaining strong post-Covid growth (e.g., apparel and grocery) and others returning to pre-Covid levels (e.g., books, furniture, and homewares).
Generalist vs Specialist
Generalist marketplaces maintain a dominant position, accounting for approximately 70% of all 3P GMV in 2022. Despite slower GMV growth, they've managed to increase revenues by expanding their offer of value-added services, achieving strong take-rate growth of 30-50% over the last five years.
Risks and Opportunities
The rise of specialist models challenges the traditional generalist model, with regional insurgents gaining market share by offering competitive pricing against leading generalists' high and increasing seller fees. Some categories may face declining marketplace penetration post-Covid, especially those where consumers prefer physical retailers, potentially limiting marketplaces' growth potential.
Emerging Trends
The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) promises to significantly impact marketplaces, enhancing consumer experiences while posing risks of disruptors taking market share or disintermediating the customer journey, particularly in areas like search. Vertical-focused, second-hand, and hyper-local marketplaces continue to emerge, offering sellers new avenues for growth and access to consumer demand.