Kazakhstan's state-owned enterprises (SOEs) play a significant role in the economy, with Samruk Kazyna (SK) and Baiterek National Managing Holding (BNMH) accounting for around 40% of GDP. Their quasi-fiscal activities, while beneficial for economic development, complicate macroeconomic management and pose contingent fiscal risks. The balance sheets of SK and BNMH have expanded significantly, particularly during economic downturns, with their growth averaging about 20% of the state budget expenditure over the past five years. If these activities were included in budgetary expenditure, the non-oil deficit would have been higher, indicating a larger fiscal expansion than officially recorded.
SOEs' financial performance has underperformed, with most subsidiaries experiencing low profitability and potential cross-subsidization within SK. Liquidity risks are also present, with some subsidiaries having current ratios below 1, indicating near-term liquidity shortfalls. These risks could materialize if commodity prices decline or financial conditions tighten.
To mitigate these risks, the government should: strengthen fiscal management frameworks to monitor SOEs' fiscal impact, enhance transparency in fiscal interactions, establish clear policies for SOE support, and accelerate privatization, particularly in non-strategic sectors. Additionally, the government should review the rationale for SOE involvement in activities that private enterprises could more efficiently serve and ensure a level playing field.
The government's plans to promote investment growth through SOEs could complicate fiscal consolidation efforts, as the expansionary off-budget activities of BNMH and SK may offset planned budgetary consolidation. This dynamic also complicates the calibration of countercyclical fiscal policy, making it harder to assess whether overall policy is restraining or stimulating demand.