The European Commission’s proposal for a fuel crediting mechanism would allow car and van manufacturers to benefit from a lower carbon dioxide (CO2) reduction target in 2035 by utilizing renewable fuels. The mechanism would enable manufacturers to comply with the 2035 targets by increasing their zero-emission vehicle (ZEV) sales share to 83% for cars and 91% for vans, instead of the 100% required under current standards.
However, broadening the mechanism by increasing the 3% cap on its contribution to 10%, lowering the lifetime mileage of vehicles, and allowing food- and feed-based fuels to count towards the credits could drop the ZEV share required for compliance to 77% for cars and 83% for vans by 2035. This weakening of the standards would result in an additional 0.7 GtCO2 of cumulative emissions relative to the Commission's proposal over the period 2027–2050.
The proposal is driven by existing obligations set for fuel suppliers through the Renewable Energy Directive (RED) and ReFuelEU Aviation regulation, and may be further incentivized by the Emissions Trading System (ETS) for road transport (ETS2). Sales of RED-compliant fuels are expected to rise due to these policies, and if the fuel crediting mechanism is broadened, manufacturers could benefit from lower CO2 targets due to this already rising share of RED-compliant fuels.
The International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) modeled the impact of broadening the fuel crediting mechanism on ZEV sales and greenhouse gas emissions. The analysis projected a gap between the CO2 emissions and the ETS2 allowances available to the road transport sector, which could be filled through the production of additional RED-compliant fuels. A production increase in these fuels of approximately 940 PJ in 2030, rising to 1,200 PJ in 2035, would be required to close this gap.
The ICCT projected the sales share of zero-emission cars and vans that would be required to comply with the CO2 standards under four scenarios: the current CO2 standards, the European Commission’s proposed amendments, the proposed amendments plus removing the 3% cap on the fuel crediting mechanism and allowing credits to count from 2027, and the proposed amendments plus increasing the 3% cap on the fuel crediting mechanism to 10%, expanding the scope of eligible fuels to include all RED-compliant fuels, and allowing credits to count from 2027. The analysis showed that increasing the 3% cap for the fuel credits to 10%, lowering the lifetime mileage, and allowing all RED-compliant fuels to count towards the fuel credits would result in ZEV shares of just 77% for cars and 83% for vans in 2035.
The ICCT concludes that the fuel crediting mechanism effectively provides manufacturers with a lower CO2 target from 2035 due to sales of biofuels and e-fuels that will be already driven to the market by existing targets in the RED and ReFuelEU Aviation, and possibly through ETS2. Any further broadening of the fuel crediting mechanism will allow manufacturers to reduce their sales of ZEVs, which may have negative consequences for Europe’s automotive sector, consumers, and emission reduction. The 3% limit should be maintained and food- and feed-based biofuels should be excluded from the scope of the fuel crediting mechanism to limit the increase in CO2 emissions and shield consumers from volatile fossil fuel prices.