asr分析报告和案例研究

Broadband Technology Opportunities ProgramEvaluation StudyOrder Number D10PD18645 Submitted September 15, 2014 ASR Analytics, LLC1389 Canterbury WayPotomac, MD 20854 Federal TIN: 20-1204680DUNS: 15-108-3305GSA Schedule #: GS-10F-0062R Final Report: Social and EconomicImpacts of the Broadband TechnologyOpportunities Program Submitted to:Shelita Saint-Louis, Contracting OfficerCassandra Sterba, Contract SpecialistAcquisition Services DirectorateNational Business CenterDepartment of the Interior Table of Contents Executive Summary............................................................................................................................ 1Section 1.Introduction ................................................................................................................... 61.1About the Evaluation Study.................................................................................................. 61.2Projects in the Evaluation Study Sample ............................................................................. 81.3BTOP Grantee Descriptive Statistics ................................................................................. 13Section 2.Short-Term Economic Impacts ................................................................................... 16Section 3.Intermediate-Term Impacts......................................................................................... 183.1Summary of Observed Intermediate-Term Impacts........................................................... 183.2Workforce and Economic Development............................................................................. 223.3Education and Training ...................................................................................................... 233.4Healthcare .......................................................................................................................... 243.5Government Services......................................................................................................... 253.6Quality of Life/Civic Engagement ....................................................................................... 253.7Digital Literacy.................................................................................................................... 26Section 4.Long-Term Impacts..................................................................................................... 284.1Summary of CCI Outcomes ............................................................................................... 284.2Effect of BTOP on Broadband Availability ......................................................................... 304.3Long-Term Impacts of BTOP CCI Infrastructure................................................................ 334.4Reduction in Broadband Costs .......................................................................................... 34Section 5.Sustainability ............................................................................................................... 375.1Introduction......................................................................................................................... 375.2Summary ............................................................................................................................ 375.3PCC.................................................................................................................................... 375.4SBA .................................................................................................................................... 395.5CCI ..................................................................................................................................... 40Section 6.Progress towards Recovery Act Goals ....................................................................... 436.1Improve Access to Unserved and Underserved Areas of the Country .............................. 446.2Broadband Education, Awareness, Training, Access, Equipment, and Support............... 446.3Public Safety Agencies ...................................................................................................... 486.4Demand for Broadband, Economic Growth, and Job Creation.......................................... 48Section 7.Best Practices ............................................................................................................. 517.1PCC and SBA..................................................................................................................... 51 7.2CCI ..................................................................................................................................... 53Appendix A.Qualitative Data Analysis Methodology................................................................... 55A.1Case Study Methodology ................................................................................................... 55A.2Data Anal