对《2018-2023年大流行性流感防范（PIP）框架伙伴关系贡献高级别实施计划》（HLIP II）的独立外部评估

Independent External Evaluation of:The Pandemic Influenza Preparedness (PIP)Framework Partnership ContributionHigh-level Implementation Plan2018-2023 (HLIP II) International Organisation Development LtdIOD PARC is the trading name of International OrganisationDevelopment LtdRegistered in England and Wales, No. 3613839Registered Office: Omega Court, 362 Cemetery Road,Sheffield, S11 8FT, United Kingdom Prepared for // WHO PIPFramework SecretariatBy // Nick York (Team Leader) /Gillian Mayers / Sonia Pérez /Ben HenryDate // 02.10.2024 Omega Court362 Cemetery RoadSheffieldS11 8FTUnited KingdomTel: +44 (0) 114 267 3620www.iodparc.com Contents Page | iiiAcknowledgements .......................................................................................... viAbbreviations................................................................................................... viiExecutive Summary ..........................................................................................1Background ......................................................................................................................1Evaluation Objective, Purpose and Scope .......................................................................1Methodology.....................................................................................................................1Findings............................................................................................................................1Key Achievements ................................................................................................................... 1Effectiveness of Resources in Meeting the Outcomes ............................................................. 2Enabling Factors...................................................................................................................... 2Constraining Factors................................................................................................................ 3Challenges, Gaps, and Areas for Improvement........................................................................ 3Conclusions and Recommendations........................................................................................ 31.Evaluation Purpose, Objectives and Scope .............................................72.Introduction ...............................................................................................82.1 Background to PIP Framework and HLIP II ................................................................83.Methodology ...........................................................................................103.1 Evaluation Approach ................................................................................................103.2 Evaluation Phases....................................................................................................113.2.1 Inception ....................................................................................................................... 113.2.2 Data Collection.............................................................................................................. 123.2.3 Data Analysis and Synthesis......................................................................................... 143.2.4 Reporting ...................................................................................................................... 143.3 Limitations ................................................................................................................154.Findings ..................................................................................................174.1 Relevance.................................................................................................................174.2 Coherence ................................................................................................................214.3 Effectiveness ............................................................................................................254.4 Efficiency ..................................................................................................................374.5 Impact.......................................................................................................................404.6 Sustainability ............................................................................................................425.Conclusions ............................................................................................456.Recommendations..................................................................................476.1Strategic................................................................................................................47Recommendation 1: Sustainability ......................................................................................... 47Recommendation 2: Integration ............................................